Roast Beef Hash Vs Corned Beef Hash: Which Will Triumph?

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

In the diverse world of comfort food, few dishes stand out quite like hash. With its crispy, golden exterior and a medley of savory flavors, hash has found its place on breakfast and brunch tables around the globe.

In this article, we’ll embark on a delightful culinary journey exploring two classic variations: Corned Beef Hash and Roast Beef Hash.

Roast Beef Hash Vs Corned Beef Hash – Quick Differences

Roast beef hash and corned beef hash are two distinct dishes, primarily differing in the type of beef used and their preparation methods:

FeatureCorned Beef HashRoast Beef Hash
Main IngredientCured beef brisket with brineLeftover roast beef
Flavor ProfileSalty and savoryMore nuanced, potential variety
TextureCrispy and brownedCrispy and golden
Cooking ProcessDiced or shredded, then cookedDiced ingredients, cooked to crisp
Culinary HeritageIrish and British traditionVersatile and adaptable
Leftover PotentialSpecific to corned beef leftoversExcellent use for roast dinner remnants
Cultural InfluenceStrong ties to Irish and British cuisinesAdaptable, less tied to specific culture
Taste PreferencesRobust, salty flavorMore diverse, depends on original roasting seasonings

In summary, the key difference lies in the type of beef used and the associated flavors.

Corned beef hash has a saltier taste due to the curing process, while roast beef hash’s flavor depends on the original roasting seasonings.

Both dishes typically include diced potatoes and onions and are cooked until crispy.

The choice between them often comes down to personal preference for the type of beef flavor you enjoy.

Ingredients Comparison

Ingredients are the foundation of any delicious dish, and when it comes to roast beef hash and corned beef hash, the ingredients play a crucial role in defining the unique flavors and textures of these comforting meals.

Let’s take a closer look at the distinct ingredients that make each dish stand out.

Roast Beef Hash Ingredients

  • Roast Beef: The star of the dish, tender and flavorful roast beef is the primary ingredient.
  • Potatoes: Diced or shredded potatoes add a hearty and starchy element to the hash.
  • Onions: Finely chopped onions bring a subtle sweetness and depth of flavor to the dish.
  • Seasonings: A blend of savory seasonings such as salt, pepper, and herbs further enhances the taste of the roast beef hash.

Corned Beef Hash Ingredients

  • Corned Beef: The key ingredient, typically leftover from a corned beef recipe or canned corned beef, gives the hash its distinct salty and spiced flavor.
  • Potatoes: Like in roast beef hash, potatoes are an essential component, providing a satisfying and filling element.
  • Onions: Similarly, onions are added to corned beef hash, contributing to its aromatic and flavorful profile.
  • Spices: A medley of spices, such as pepper, paprika, and garlic powder, further elevate the taste and complexity of corned beef hash.


Making Roast Beef Hash

Roast beef hash is a savory and hearty dish that can be easily prepared at home.

To make roast beef hash, follow these simple steps:

  1. Cook a beef roast as a large cut of seasoned meat.
  2. Once the roast is cooked, let it cool slightly and then shred the beef into small, bite-sized pieces.
  3. In a separate pan, fry diced potatoes until they are crispy and golden brown.
  4. Add the shredded beef to the pan with the potatoes and season with salt, pepper, and any other desired spices or herbs.
  5. Cook the mixture until the flavors meld together and the beef is heated through.
  6. Serve hot and enjoy the delicious combination of tender roast beef and crispy potatoes.

Making Corned Beef Hash

Corned beef hash is a comforting dish made from leftovers. Here’s how you can make your own corned beef hash:

  1. Start by gathering your ingredients: chopped corned beef (either canned or homemade), cooked potatoes or frozen hash browns, onions, and spices.
  2. In a frying pan, heat some oil or butter and add the onions. Sauté them until they become translucent.
  3. Add the corned beef to the pan and cook it until it starts to brown slightly.
  4. Next, add the cooked potatoes or hash browns to the pan, breaking them up into smaller pieces.
  5. Sprinkle in your preferred spices, such as salt, pepper, and paprika, to enhance the flavor.
  6. Continue cooking the mixture until the potatoes are crispy and the flavors meld together.
  7. For an extra touch, you can serve corned beef hash with poached or fried eggs on top.

Both roast beef hash and corned beef hash are delicious breakfast options that offer a satisfying and flavorful experience.

While roast beef hash showcases the tenderness of slow-cooked roast beef, corned beef hash combines the flavors of cured corned beef with crispy potatoes.

Whether you prefer the richness of roast beef or the saltiness of corned beef, these hashes are sure to please your taste buds.

Flavor Profile Comparison

Roast beef hash is made from tender, slow-cooked roast beef that is diced and combined with potatoes and seasonings.

The flavor of roast beef hash can be described as rich, savory, and meaty. The slow cooking process ensures that the beef is tender and flavorful, while the potatoes add a subtle earthiness to the dish.

The seasonings complement the beef’s natural juices, resulting in a robust and satisfying flavor profile.

Corned beef hash, on the other hand, is typically made from leftover corned beef that has been chopped and combined with cooked potatoes, onions, and spices.

The flavor of corned beef hash is distinctively salty and spiced, thanks to the curing process of the corned beef.

The brine used in the curing infuses the meat with a unique blend of herbs and spices, giving it a bold and zesty taste.

The combination of corned beef, potatoes, and spices creates a flavorful and satisfying dish.

Overall, roast beef hash offers a rich and meaty flavor, while corned beef hash provides a salty and spiced taste.

The choice between the two depends on whether you prefer a robust and savory flavor or a bold and zesty one. Both dishes are delicious and can be enjoyed for a hearty breakfast.


When comparing Roast Beef Hash to Corned Beef Hash, the texture differs as Roast Beef Hash incorporates tender roast beef and diced potatoes creating a chunkier and heartier consistency, while Corned Beef Hash consists of chopped corned beef and cooked potatoes for a softer and more blended texture.

When it comes to texture, roast beef hash offers a delightful combination of tenderness and crispiness.

The roast beef is diced into small pieces, creating a chunky and substantial texture. As it cooks, the meat becomes incredibly tender, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth experience.

Additionally, the potatoes in roast beef hash have a soft texture that adds a creamy element to each bite.

The exterior of the hash develops a satisfying crispy crust, offering a pleasant contrast of textures.

Overall, roast beef hash provides a satisfying mouthfeel that is sure to please any meat lover.

Corned beef hash, on the other hand, boasts a slightly different texture that is equally enjoyable.

The corned beef, which has been cured in a brine, has a salty and spiced flavor that infuses the dish.

As the corned beef cooks, it becomes tender and easily breaks apart, creating a softer texture compared to roast beef hash.

The potatoes in corned beef hash are also cooked until they are tender and give a creamy consistency to the dish.

The overall texture of corned beef hash is smoother and more uniform, with a rich and savory mouthfeel.

Which hash variation is more popular in traditional Irish cuisine?

In traditional Irish cuisine, Corned Beef Hash is more commonly associated with culinary practices.

The use of corned beef in Ireland has historical roots, particularly as a preservation method for meat.

While the association of corned beef with Irish cuisine is more notable in international perceptions, it’s important to note that dietary preferences and regional variations within Ireland itself can influence the popularity of specific dishes.

Roast Beef Hash, on the other hand, may have a broader appeal in various culinary contexts but might not be as closely tied to traditional Irish culinary practices.

Can I use any type of beef for both Roast Beef Hash and Corned Beef Hash?

While you technically can use different types of beef for both Roast Beef Hash and Corned Beef Hash, the distinct flavors and characteristics of each dish are best achieved by using the specific types of beef traditionally associated with them.

Roast Beef Hash:

Ideally, leftover roast beef from a previous meal is used. This beef has been roasted, allowing it to develop its unique flavor and texture.

Using other cuts of beef might alter the intended taste and may not provide the same richness associated with roast beef hash.

Corned Beef Hash:

Corned beef is the traditional choice for this dish. It undergoes a curing process with specific seasonings, giving it a distinct salty and savory flavor.

Using a different type of beef would not capture the unique taste that comes from the curing process.

Can Roast Beef Hash and Corned Beef Hash be part of a vegetarian or vegan diet?

Adapting Roast Beef Hash and Corned Beef Hash to fit a vegetarian or vegan diet involves creative substitutions while ensuring the flavors and textures align with dietary preferences.

For a Vegetarian Roast Beef Hash, the traditional roast beef can be replaced with vegetarian or plant-based protein options such as textured vegetable protein (TVP), seitan, or marinated and roasted mushrooms.

It’s crucial to choose substitutes with a hearty texture to mimic the satisfying feel of roast beef in the dish.

Similarly, a Vegan Roast Beef Hash can be achieved by opting for plant-based protein sources. This might include using alternatives like TVP, seitan, or roasted and marinated mushrooms, ensuring all ingredients, including seasonings, adhere to vegan dietary guidelines.

For those interested in a Vegetarian Corned Beef Hash, consider replacing the corned beef with vegetarian alternatives like tempeh or marinated and sautéed jackfruit.

The addition of savory spices can help replicate the distinct flavor profile associated with traditional corned beef.

Likewise, a Vegan Corned Beef Hash can be crafted using plant-based protein sources and ensuring all components, including potatoes and onions, adhere to vegan dietary preferences.

Experimenting with various seasonings is key to achieving a savory and slightly salty taste reminiscent of corned beef.

When adapting these classic dishes for a vegetarian or vegan diet, attention to flavor balance and texture is crucial to creating a satisfying eating experience.

Individuals with specific dietary restrictions or preferences may also explore specialized plant-based recipes that capture the essence of hash while meeting their unique needs and tastes.


In the end, whether you’re a fan of the salty allure of Corned Beef Hash or the elegant simplicity of Roast Beef Hash, both dishes offer a comforting symphony of flavors and textures. Whichever hash adventure you choose, relish in the joy of savoring classic comfort food that transcends time and borders.

So, the next time you find yourself yearning for a hearty breakfast or brunch, consider embarking on a culinary journey through the delicious world of hash.

Leave a Comment