Undercooked Gnocchi: Causes, Fixes, Signs, and Preventions

Every product is independently reviewed and selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Gnocchi, those delightful potato dumplings, can sometimes pose a culinary challenge when they turn out undercooked.

In this article, we’ll explore the reasons behind undercooked gnocchi, how to identify the signs, and most importantly, how to fix and prevent this common kitchen woe.

Is it bad to eat undercooked gnocchi?

Yes, it is bad to eat undercooked gnocchi because eating undercooked gnocchi can potentially pose some risks, especially if they contain raw or undercooked ingredients.

Gnocchi are typically made with potatoes, flour, and sometimes eggs. If the gnocchi dough is not cooked through, there is a risk of consuming raw or undercooked ingredients, which may carry the possibility of bacterial contamination, particularly if eggs are part of the recipe.

Eating raw or undercooked eggs can expose you to the risk of foodborne illnesses such as salmonella.

Additionally, undercooked potatoes may contain compounds like solanine, which can be harmful in large quantities.

How to know if gnocchi is undercooked?

Determining if gnocchi is undercooked can be done by assessing its texture and appearance.

Here are some signs that gnocchi may be undercooked:

Hard and Dense Texture:

Undercooked gnocchi will be dense and may have a doughy or raw texture. When properly cooked, gnocchi should be soft, light, and pillowy.

Sticky or Gummy Texture:

If the gnocchi sticks together and feels gummy or overly sticky, it may not have been cooked long enough. Properly cooked gnocchi should have a tender and slightly chewy texture.

Floating Too Quickly:

When boiling gnocchi, they initially sink to the bottom of the pot and then float to the surface as they cook.

If they float too quickly, it might indicate that they haven’t cooked long enough. Allow them to float for a bit before removing them from the water.

Pale Color:

Gnocchi should have a slightly pale appearance when cooked. If they still look pale or have a raw dough color, they may need more time.

Taste Test:

Take a small piece of gnocchi and taste it. If it feels doughy, raw, or unpleasantly firm, it is likely undercooked.

How to Fix Undercooked Gnocchi – 2 Methods

If your gnocchi is undercooked, you can fix it by re-boiling in simmering water for a few minutes.

Alternatively, you can pan-fry it with butter to achieve a crispy exterior while the inside finishes cooking.

Another method is to bake it in the oven until it reaches the desired texture.

Returning Undercooked Gnocchi To Boiling Water

There are simple methods to return undercooked gnocchi to boiling water and ensure they are perfectly cooked.

In this section, we’ll discuss two methods – the re-boiling method and the simmering method – that will salvage your undercooked gnocchi and give you a delicious meal.

Re-boiling Method

If your gnocchi is undercooked, the re-boiling method is a quick and effective way to fix the issue.

Here’s how:

  1. Bring a pot of water to a rolling boil. Make sure the pot is large enough to hold the gnocchi without crowding.
  2. Add the undercooked gnocchi to the boiling water. Make sure to gently separate any gnocchi that are sticking together.
  3. Boil the gnocchi for an additional 2-3 minutes, or until they float to the surface. This indicates that they are fully cooked.
  4. Using a slotted spoon or a spider strainer, remove the cooked gnocchi from the pot and transfer them to a colander or a plate.
  5. Drizzle some olive oil or melted butter over the cooked gnocchi to prevent them from sticking together.
  6. Your gnocchi is now ready to be served! Enjoy them with your favorite sauce or toppings.

Simmering Method

The simmering method is another option to fix undercooked gnocchi.

Follow these steps:

  • In a large saucepan, bring water to a simmer. Make sure there’s enough water to fully submerge the gnocchi.
  • Add the undercooked gnocchi to the simmering water. Stir gently to prevent them from sticking together.
  • Allow the gnocchi to simmer for an additional 2-3 minutes. You can check for doneness by cutting a piece of gnocchi in half – it should be cooked through with no raw doughy center.
  • Once the gnocchi is fully cooked, carefully remove it from the simmering water using a slotted spoon or a spider strainer.
  • Drain the gnocchi in a colander and rinse them with cold water to halt the cooking process.
  • Your gnocchi is now ready to be used in your desired recipe or enjoyed on its own.

Sautéing Undercooked Gnocchi In A Pan

This method helps to cook the gnocchi evenly and gives them a delicious crispy exterior.

Here’s how you can do it:

Using Oil Or Butter

To sauté undercooked gnocchi, start by heating a pan over medium heat. Once the pan is hot, add a tablespoon of oil or butter.

The choice between oil or butter depends on your preference and the flavor you want to achieve.

If you prefer a lighter taste, opt for a neutral oil such as canola or vegetable oil. On the other hand, if you want a richer flavor, butter is the way to go.

Adding Herbs And Seasonings

While the oil or butter is heating, take this opportunity to enhance the flavor of your gnocchi by adding herbs and seasonings.

Common herbs like basil, parsley, and thyme work wonders with gnocchi. Sprinkle them over the hot oil or butter and let them release their aromatic fragrance.

If you’re looking for more depth of flavor, you can add minced garlic or diced onions as well.

Sauté them until they soften and become fragrant, giving your undercooked gnocchi an extra burst of flavor.

Once your oil or butter is hot and your herbs and seasonings are added, it’s time to introduce the undercooked gnocchi to the pan.

Spread them out in a single layer, ensuring each gnocchi has enough space to cook evenly.

Allow them to cook for a couple of minutes, until they start to turn golden brown on one side.

Using a spatula or tongs, flip the gnocchi over to cook the other side. Continue cooking for another few minutes until all the gnocchi are golden brown and crispy on the outside.

Be careful not to overcook them, as you still want the inside to be soft and tender.

Once your gnocchi are perfectly sautéed, remove them from the pan and serve immediately.

They can be enjoyed on their own as a snack or as a side dish alongside your favorite sauce or toppings.

Can You Microwave Undercooked Gnocchi?

Yes, you can microwave undercooked gnocchi to finish cooking them. However, microwaving might not be the ideal method for cooking gnocchi, as it may result in uneven cooking and a different texture compared to boiling or pan-frying.

If your gnocchi are undercooked, it’s generally recommended to finish cooking them using the original cooking method.

If you initially boiled the gnocchi, you can return them to boiling water until they are fully cooked.

If you pan-fried them, you can put them back in a hot pan with a bit of oil or butter and cook until they reach the desired doneness.

Adjust the cooking time accordingly to ensure they are cooked through without becoming mushy.

While microwaving can be a quick option, it might not give you the best results in terms of texture and flavor for gnocchi.

How long does it take to cook gnocchi?

The cooking time for gnocchi can vary depending on the size and thickness of the gnocchi, as well as the cooking method you’re using.

Here are general guidelines for cooking gnocchi using different methods:

Boiling Gnocchi:

Fresh Gnocchi: Typically, fresh gnocchi takes about 2-4 minutes to cook. They will float to the surface of the boiling water when they are done.

Once they float, give them another 30 seconds to a minute and then remove them.

Store-Bought or Frozen Gnocchi: These may take a bit longer, usually around 3-5 minutes. Follow the package instructions for the recommended cooking time.

Pan-Frying Gnocchi:

Pan-frying gnocchi can take about 5-7 minutes. Heat a skillet with some butter or oil over medium-high heat and cook the gnocchi until they are golden brown on the outside. This method gives the gnocchi a slightly crispy exterior.

Baking Gnocchi:

Baking gnocchi in the oven can take approximately 20-25 minutes. Toss the gnocchi with sauce and any desired toppings, then bake until they are heated through and the edges are golden.

It’s essential to follow the specific instructions provided in your recipe or on the package if you’re using store-bought gnocchi.

Additionally, you can check for doneness by cutting a piece of gnocchi open; it should have a consistent texture throughout without any raw or doughy areas.

Keep in mind that overcooking gnocchi can lead to a mushy texture, so it’s important to find the right balance to achieve the desired softness without overdoing it.

Why Are My Gnocchi Undercooked? Common Causes

Undercooked gnocchi can result from boiling them for too short a time or using insufficient heat, not rolling them correctly, or using old potatoes.

To fix this, simply return the undercooked gnocchi to boiling water for a few more minutes until they are cooked through.

Inadequate Boiling Time

One of the most common causes of undercooked gnocchi is inadequate boiling time. Gnocchi is typically cooked by boiling it until it floats to the surface of the water.

This indicates that it is cooked throughout and ready to be served. However, if you remove the gnocchi from the water too soon, it may be undercooked and have a doughy or gummy texture.

Using Wrong Type Of Potato

Using the wrong type of potato can also result in undercooked gnocchi. The best type of potato to use for making gnocchi is starchy potatoes, such as Russet or Idaho.

These potatoes have a high starch content and less moisture, making them ideal for creating light and fluffy gnocchi.

Using waxy or low-starch potatoes can lead to a denser texture and undercooked centers.

Incorrect Measurement Of Ingredients

Incorrectly measuring the ingredients for your gnocchi dough can also contribute to undercooked gnocchi.

It’s important to follow the recipe instructions precisely and measure your ingredients accurately.

Using too much flour can result in a dense and dry dough, whereas using too little flour can cause the gnocchi to fall apart during cooking. Balance is key to achieving perfectly cooked gnocchi.

How To Prevent Undercooked Gnocchi?

Undercooked gnocchi can be disappointing, as it can ruin the overall texture and taste of your dish.

However, with a few simple tips, you can ensure your gnocchi turns out perfectly cooked every time.

In this section, we will discuss three key factors that can help prevent undercooked gnocchi: cooking time awareness, choosing the right potatoes, and accurate ingredient measurements.

Cooking Time Awareness

Being aware of the cooking time of your gnocchi is crucial to prevent it from being undercooked.

Overcooking can make the gnocchi too soft and mushy, while undercooking can leave it dense and doughy.

It’s essential to follow the cooking instructions provided with your gnocchi recipe or package, as different types and brands may have varying cooking times.

Keep a close eye on the gnocchi while cooking, and once they float to the surface, give them a gentle stir and cook for an additional 1-2 minutes.

Choosing The Right Potatoes

The type of potatoes you use can greatly impact the texture and consistency of your gnocchi.

For light and fluffy gnocchi, it is best to use starchy potatoes such as russet or Yukon Gold.

These potatoes have a higher starch content, which results in a lighter texture. Avoid using waxy potatoes like red or new potatoes, as they have a lower starch content and can make your gnocchi heavy and dense.

Boiling the potatoes with their skins on can help prevent excess moisture from being absorbed, resulting in a better gnocchi texture.

Accurate Ingredient Measurements

Accurate measurements of ingredients are crucial when making gnocchi. Using too much flour can make the dough too heavy and result in undercooked gnocchi.

On the other hand, using too little flour can make the dough too sticky and difficult to work with.

Follow the recipe’s specific measurements for potatoes, flour, and any other ingredients to ensure the right balance and consistency for your gnocchi dough.

Additionally, avoid overworking the dough, as this can also lead to undercooked gnocchi. Keep the mixing and kneading to a minimum, just until the dough comes together.

What  undercooked gnocchi taste like?

Undercooked gnocchi can have an unpleasant taste and texture. When gnocchi is not cooked through, it retains a doughy, starchy flavor that might be reminiscent of raw flour or uncooked potatoes.

The texture is typically dense, sticky, and lacking the light and pillowy quality that well-cooked gnocchi should have.

Is Gnocchi Supposed to Be Doughy?

No, properly cooked gnocchi should not be doughy. Gnocchi should have a tender and pillowy texture.

When cooked correctly, they are light, soft, and slightly chewy, with a delicate flavor. If gnocchi is doughy, it may be a sign that it is undercooked and needs more time to cook through.

Is Gnocchi Undercooked if Chewy?

Yes, gnocchi is likely undercooked if it is overly chewy. While gnocchi should have a slight chewiness to them, they should not be excessively tough or rubbery.

If the gnocchi has a dense and chewy texture, it indicates that it needs more cooking time to achieve the desired tenderness. Properly cooked gnocchi should be tender and easy to bite into.

Is Gnocchi Supposed to Be Crispy?

Gnocchi is not traditionally supposed to be crispy, but some recipes call for pan-frying gnocchi to achieve a slightly crispy exterior.

Pan-frying involves cooking the gnocchi in a skillet with oil or butter until the outside becomes golden brown.

This method can add a different texture to the gnocchi, with a crispy outer layer and a soft interior.

If your recipe calls for crispy gnocchi, it’s intentional and part of the desired outcome.

Traditional boiling or baking methods result in soft and tender gnocchi without a crispy texture.

How Tender Should Gnocchi Be?

Gnocchi should be tender but not overly mushy. When properly cooked, gnocchi have a delicate and pillowy texture with a slight chewiness.

They should be soft enough to bite into easily without being dense or gummy. The goal is to achieve a balance between a tender interior and a slight resistance when you bite into them.


Mastering the art of cooking gnocchi involves a delicate balance of ingredients and techniques. By understanding the causes of undercooked gnocchi, recognizing the signs, and implementing the fixes and preventative measures discussed in this article, you’ll be well on your way to creating perfect, pillowy gnocchi every time.

Happy cooking!

Leave a Comment